In Force

BIPM Rapport

BIPM BIPM-2019/06 : 2019
Purity Evaluation Guideline: Zearalenone [PEG-01]
Steven Westwood (BIPM), Ralf Josephs (BIPM), Tiphaine Choteau (BIPM), Xiuqin Li (NIM, China), Bruno Garrido (INMETRO, Brazil), Ilker Un (TUBITAK UME, Turkey), Taichi Yamazaki (NMIJ, Japan).
BIPM Rapport

In Force



Purity Evaluation Guideline: Zearalenone [PEG-01]

1.  Scope

This document has been prepared to provide guidance for the value assignment of the mass fraction of zearalenone (ZEN) present in a purified solid ZEN material intended for use as Primary Reference Material.

The information summarized in the document was obtained as part of the BIPM Metrology for Safe Food and Feed Programme for Capacity Building and Knowledge Transfer on the production and characterization of reference materials for mycotoxin analysis.

2.  Introduction

In collaboration with the National Institute of Metrology, China (NIM) and the National Metrology Institute of South Africa (NMISA), the BIPM initiated in 2016 a Capacity Building and Knowledge Transfer program for Metrology for Safe Food and Feed in Developing Economies. [1] This project is designed to allow NMIs to work together to strengthen the worldwide mycotoxin metrology infrastructure; provide knowledge transfer to scientists developing capabilities in this area and to enable NMIs in developing regions to provide calibrants, matrix reference materials and proficiency test samples that support testing activities and laboratory services for mycotoxin analysis within their countries.

As for all other areas of organic analysis primary reference materials consisting of well characterized, high purity compounds are required for each analyte subject to investigation. These materials are the source of higher-order metrological traceability for the assigned values of derived calibration solutions, reference materials, proficiency test samples and ultimately the results of routine analysis. Access to pure organic compounds and calibration solutions prepared from these materials is an essential element in the measurement infrastructure supporting the delivery of reliable, comparable results. In the case of mycotoxins purity analysis of source materials involves additional challenges linked to the limited amount of available material and its potential toxicity.

Zearalenone, a fungal secondary metabolite produced by Fusarium spp, is a frequent contaminant of food and animal feed, in particular of maize but is also found in barley, oats and wheat. [2], [3] It is a non-steroid estrogenic compound which can cause changes in reproductive organs and fertility loss and has been shown to have several other toxic effects. [4] The ability to undertake robust and reliable analysis for zearalenone and related compounds is required for health and food safety and for trade in primary produce for countries which produce or consume large quantities of corn grains and wheat. [5]

An essential requirement of this project was to obtain and characterize a primary reference material for zearalenone that could be used subsequently to establish a calibration heirarchy to underpin the metrological traceability of results linked through calibration to this material. [6] This guideline summarizes characterization and purity assignment studies to assess identity and purity of a Primary Reference Material [7] for zearalenone used to deliver the BIPM MMCBKT program and is intended to be of use to other metrology institutes and reference measurement service providers needing to characterize their own source material for zearalenone analysis. Particular reliance was placed on nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) studies both to confirm the qualitative identity of the main component of the material and to assign the mass fraction content of zearalenone it contained.

Due to the relatively complex structure of zearalenone, the assignment by qNMR only provides in the first instance an estimate of the total zearalenone and related structure impurity content. This initial value needed to be corrected for the relevant related structure impurity content as assigned separately by LC-MS/MS and LC-DAD methods to give the final value for the absolute zearalenone content of the material. Additional analyses for the assessment of other potential impurities were undertaken to support and confirm the value assigned through combination of the qNMR and LC data.

3.  Nomenclature and Ring numbering

Throughout this report the nomenclature and abbreviations proposed by Metzler [8] for the specification of zearalenone and related compounds are used. Zearalenone is abbreviated as ZEN, while noting that in other literature ZON or ZEA are also used for the same structure. The abbreviations for the related zearalenols which retain the alkene bond in the macrocyclic ring are based on ZEL and those for the zearalanols, in which the ring alkene bond is no longer present, are based on ZAL.

For the numbering of the carbon skeleton the IUPAC system which assigns the C-atoms of ZEN from 1–18 is used. This supercedes systems based on use of the numbers 1–6 for the aromatic ring and 1’–12’ for the aliphatic carbons of the macrocyclic ring. The structure of ZEN with the current and historical ring numbering schemes are shown respectively in Figure 1 and Figure 2.

The full structures and abbreviations for ZEN, its related metabolite family and impurities identified in the course of this work program are shown in Appendix A1.1.

4.  Properties of Zearalenone

4.1.  Hazard Identification

The substance poses high potential risks for human health if handled inappropriately. It is toxic by inhalation, in contact with skin and if swallowed. Exposure to ZEN may cause cancer.

DISCLAIMER: The safety recommendations given in this section are based on literature reported best practice and have not been verified by the BIPM.

4.1.1.  Protective measures

Avoid breathing of dust, vapours, mist or gas. Wear full-face particulate filtering respirator type N100 (US) or type P3 (EN 143) respirator cartridges when working with the solid material. Wear protective gloves, goggles and clothing. Take special care to avoid skin exposure if handling solutions and work in adequately ventilated areas. Wash hands thoroughly after handling.

4.1.2.  Emergency procedures

General advice

Immediately call a POISON CENTER or doctor/physician. Show this safety data sheet to the doctor in attendance. Move out of dangerous area.

If inhaled

Move person into fresh air. If not breathing give artificial respiration. Consult a physician.

In case of skin contact

Wash off with soap and plenty of water. Consult a physician.

In case of eye contact

Rinse thoroughly with plenty of water for at least 15 minutes and consult a physician.

If swallowed

Immediately call a POISON CENTRE or doctor/physician. Never give anything by mouth to an unconscious person. Rinse mouth with water.

4.1.3.  Spillage / Projections

Contain spillage and then collect by wet-brushing and place in container for disposal. Keep in suitable, closed containers for disposal according to local regulations.

4.2.  Physical and Chemical Properties

Common Name:Zearalenone
IUPAC Name:(3S,11E)-14,16-Dihydroxy-3-methyl-3,4,5,6,9,10-hexahydro-1H-2-benzoxacyclotetradecine-1,7(8H)-dione
Synonyms:(S)-Zearalenone, trans-Zearalenone, ZEN, ZON, ZEA
CAS Registry Number:17924-92-4
Molecular Formula:C18H22O5
Molar Mass:318.364g/mol
Monoisotopic mass:318.147
Melting point:187189°C (D/L) ; 164165°C (L) [9]
Appearance:White crystalline powder
Solubility:

Insoluble in water; soluble in aqueous alkali.
Slightly soluble in hexane; progressively more soluble in benzene, acetonitrile, methylene chloride, chloroform, methanol, ethanol, acetone and DMSO.

UV maxima

CH3OH: 236nm ( ε = 29 , 700 ), 274nm (13,909), 316nm (6,020) [9]
CH3CN: 274nm ( ε = 12 , 623 ± 111 ) [10]

4.3.  Structure

Figure 1 — Structure of ZEN with IUPAC-recommended ring numbering

Figure 2 — Structure of ZEN with alternative ring numbering scheme

4.4.  Qualitative NMR

4.4.1.  Materials and methods

Chemicals:

  • Zearalenone (ZEN); BIPM Reference OGO.178a
    Supplier: First Standard, Product No. 1ST7204, Lot ALT601341

NMR Solvents:

  • Dimethylsulfoxide- d 6 (DMSO- d 6 ); BIPM Reference OGS.027c

  • Deuterated chloroform (CDCl3); BIPM Reference OGS.026b

  • Acetone- d 6 ; BIPM Reference OGS.029

Solvents were purchased from a commercial supplier and used without further treatment.

4.4.2.  Sample preparation

For qualitative NMR analyses an individual sample size of approximately 10mg of ZEN was made up in 1mL of deuterated solvent in a glass vial. The sample solution was mixed in a vortex shaker and transferred into NMR tubes (HG-Type: high grade class, 8in , 5mm o.d., with PE caps) using disposable glass pasteur pipettes.

4.4.3.  NMR acquisition parameters

A JEOL ECS-400 spectrometer operating at 9.4T (400MHz for proton) equipped with a direct type automatic tuning (Royal) probe was used for all data acquisition. For qualitative analyses, 1H spectra were acquired for both solvent blank and the ZEN sample using a simple pulse-acquire sequence with the parameters presented in Table 1.

Table 1.  Acquisition parameters for exploratory 1H analyses.

ParameterValue
Number of Transients512
Receiver gain34
Acquisition time (s )3.27
Relaxation delay (s )1.0
Pulse offset (ppm)7.0
Spectral width (ppm)20.0
Data points32768
Temperature (K )298
SpinningOff

13C experiments were conducted using an ordinary power gated sequence (pulse-acquire in 13C channel with proton decoupling both during acquisition and the relaxation delay) using the parameters shown in Table 2.

Table 2.  Acquisition parameters used for 13C analyses.

ParameterValue
Number of Transients1024
Receiver gain50
Acquisition time (s )1.04
Relaxation delay (s )2.0
Pulse offset (ppm)100
Spectral width (ppm)250
Data points32768
Temperature (K )298
SpinningOff

4.4.4.  1D 1H and 13C spectra

The simple 1H and 13C NMR spectra of the ZEN material are shown in Figure 3 and Figure 4. The results obtained were consistent with literature assignments. [10], [11] Figure 5 shows the attached proton test (APT) 13C spectrum of ZEN. Inverted signals correspond to methylene or quaternary carbons and normal signals to methine or methyl carbons.

Figure 3 — 1H NMR spectrum of the ZEN in CDCl3.

Figure 4 — 13C spectrum of ZEN in CDCl3.

Figure 5 — APT spectrum of ZEN. Down = CH2/Cq; Up = CH/CH3.

4.4.5.  2D NMR spectra

To confirm the identification and assignment of the signals, two-dimensional homonuclear correlated spectroscopy (COSY), heteronuclear single-quantum correlation spectroscopy (HSQC) and total correlation spectroscopy (TOCSY) spectra [11], [12] were acquired. The individual spectra are reproduced in Appendix A1.2. From the combined data the peak assignments are summarized in Table 3 below. The results are fully consistent with the literature assignments and established the identity of the main component in the material as ZEN.

Table 3.  1H and 13C peak assignments for ZEN in OGO.178.a.

ZEN1H-NMR (ppm)a13C-NMR (ppm)COSYHSQC (ppm)
1-171.5--
21.38 (3H)21.0Couples with 5.00 onlyCouples with 20.9
35.0073.6Couples with 1.38 and 1.64Couples with 73.5
41.64 (2H)34.9Couples with 1.38 and 1.76Couples with 34.8
51.76 (2H)22.4Couples with 1.64, 2.16 and 2.61Couples with 22.4
62.16 and 2.6143.1

2.16 with 1.76 and 2.61
2.61 with 1.76 and 2.16

Both with 43.0
7-211.8--
82.22 and 2.8636.8

2.22 with 1.50 and 2.86
2.86 with 1.50, 2.16 and 2.86

Both with 36.8
91.50 and 2.1621.2

1.50 with 2.16, 2.22 and 2.86
2.16 with 1.50, 2.37,2.86 and 5.68

Both with 21.1
102.37 and 2.1631.2

2.16 with 1.76, 2.37, 5.68
2.37 with 1.76, 2.16, 5.68, 7.01

Both with 31.1
115.68132.6Couples with 2.16, 2.37 and 7.01Couples with 132.6
127.01133.3Couples with 2.37 and 5.68Couples with 133.1
136.41108.6Couples with 6.35 onlyCouples with 108.5
14-165.6--
156.35102.6Couples with 6.41 onlyCouples with 102.5
16-160.7--
17-104.0--
18-144.2--
14-OH5.87---
16-OH12.06---

a  All reported 1H signals correspond to one proton except where noted in brackets

4.4.6.  Residual solvent content by NMR

In the 1H NMR spectrum of the BIPM material it was possible to detect impurity peaks not present in the solvent blank originating from residual solvents: a singlet at 5.3ppm from dichloromethane, a singlet at 3.33ppm from methanol and a quartet at 3.5ppm which could be either ethanol or diethyl ether. The latter is the more likely according to previously reported chemical shifts. [13]

To obtain an accurate quantification of these small signals a spectrum was acquired using 512 transients, a relaxation delay of 60s between scans and applying the parameters optimized for quantitative analysis of ZEN (see Table 5 in Section 5.2). From this spectrum, the mass fractions of the residual solvents were calculated from the ratio of the signal integral to that of reference peaks in the ZEN spectrum. Two possible scenarios for the origin of the quartet at 3.5ppm (either ethanol or diethyl ether) were considered. Two different ZEN peaks were used as reference values and the average values were considered as fit-for-purpose estimates of the mass fractions of the residual solvent content. To investigate the possibility that the quantification of these residual solvent peaks was influenced by contributions from 13C satellite peaks of adjacent ZEN peaks an acquisition using 13C-decoupling and otherwise the same parameters was also performed and the results compared.

The data from the two experiments (with and without 13C-decoupling) with calculation relative to two different ZEN peaks provided a combined result derived from the four calculated values for the levels of each residual solvent. The measurement uncertainty for this result includes contributions from the uncertainty in the molar masses of both ZEN and the solvents in addition to the pooled variation between the different measurement procedures (2 peaks, 2 acquisitions). The difference in the combined residual solvent content due uncertainty in whether ethanol or diethyl ether is present is negligible, but in order to maintain metrological traceability, an additional uncertainty component was added to take this into account. On the basis of the observed chemical shift the more likely identity is diethyl ether. If desired the identities of the residual solvents could be independently established and quantified using headspace GC-MS based technique. The results for residual solvent content assigned by the relative NMR response and their associated measurement uncertainties are summarized in Table 4. Representative spectra showing each solvent signal relative to the adjacent ZEN peaks are given in Appendix A1.4.

Table 4.  Estimated mass fraction content of the residual solvents detected in the OGO.178a material.

SolventMass fraction (mg/g ) U 95   mg/g
k = 2
CH2Cl21.280.023
MeOH0.180.004
Et2O0.470.053
Total1.930.06

4.5.  UV-Vis spectrophotometry

Methods were developed for wavelength scan and fixed wavelength measurements:

Scan wavelength:

  • Deuterium lamp: on

  • Tungsten lamp: on

  • Scan from 370.00nm to 190.00nm

  • Data interval: 1.00nm , scan speed: 266.75nm/min

  • Slit: 2nm

Fixed wavelength:

  • Deuterium lamp: on

  • Tungsten lamp: on

  • Wavelengths: 235nm , 274nm and 314nm (for OGP.025, only 274nm and 235nm )

  • Cycle: 3

  • Slit: 1nm

  • Gain: Auto

  • Response 0.2s

  • No cell changer
    Reference cell contains pure acetonitrile.
    Temperature was controlled and fixed at 20°C .

Minimum sample intake: 50µL

Equivalent UV data for ZEN is reported in reference [10]

4.6.  Mass spectrometry

Reference MS and MS/MS data for ZEN under a variety of ionization conditions are available under the entry for “zearalenone” from various open access online databases including the European Mass Bank, the Mass Bank of North America and PubChem.

5.  Purity assignment of Zearalenone

5.1.  Introduction

This section of the Guideline describes the approach developed during the BIPM MMCBKT program for the purity assignment of the ZEN source material. It is based on a quantitative NMR (qNMR) measurement [14], [15] to quantify the total ZEN and related structure impurity content with correction of the raw qNMR result for the ZEN-related impurity content quantified by LC methods.

The qualitative identity of the ZEN material was established and an estimate of residual solvent impurity content in the material was obtained using the combination of 1D- and 2D-NMR techniques described in Section 4.4 above. This identification was supported by determination of the mass spectrometric and UV-Vis spectrophotometric properties of the material. The assignment of the ZEN content by qNMR through the selection of quantification peak(s), the identification of an appropriate internal standard and the choice of a deuterated solvent is described in Section 4.2.

The development and application of methods for the identification and quantification of the ZEN-related impurity content of the material by LC-MS/MS and LC-DAD is described in Section 4.3. These results were used to correct the “raw” qNMR value for ZEN and ZEN-related impurity content in the source material to give the final assignment of the actual ZEN content of the material.

Supporting analyses undertaken to detect other impurity classes are summarized in Section 4.4 and the selection and combination of the data to give the final purity assignment of the material is described in Section 4.5.

Another approach for the purity assignment of ZEN has been reported through a combination of data obtained by NMR, LC-MS, UV spectrophotometry and DSC. [10]

DISCLAIMER: Commercial NMR and LC instruments, software and materials are identified in this document in order to describe some procedures. This does not imply a recommendation or endorsement by the BIPM nor does it imply than any of the instruments, equipment and materials identified are necessarily the best available for the purpose.

5.2.  qNMR

5.2.1.  Materials

Chemicals

  • Zearalenone (ZEN); BIPM Reference OGO.178a
    Supplier: First Standard, Product No. 1ST7204, Lot ALT601341

  • Zearalanone (ZAN); BIPM Reference OGO.182a
    Supplier: First Standard, Product No. 1ST7203, Lot LZ106742

  • Dimethylterephthalate (DMTP); BIPM Reference OGE.022b was used as the qNMR internal standard [16]. The mass fraction content of DMTP in the material was assigned as 999.3±0.8mg/g  k=2 by qNMR at the BIPM.

NMR Solvents:

  • Acetone- d 6 ; BIPM Reference OGS.029

  • Dimethylsulfoxide- d 6 (DMSO- d 6 ); BIPM Reference OGS.027c

  • Deuterated chloroform (CDCl3); BIPM Reference OGS.026b

Deuterated solvents were purchased from a commercial supplier and used without further treatment. NMR tubes were HG-Type: high grade class, 8in , 5mm diameter rated for use with 600MHz spectrometers fitted with PE caps.

5.2.2.  Sample preparation

Gravimetric operations were performed using a Mettler Toledo XP2U ultramicrobalance. Prior to all weighing operations the repeatability of the balance was assessed for suitability to the preparation of qNMR samples by repeat mass determinations of an empty weigh boat. The general recommendations of Yamazaki et al [17] for qNMR sample preparation were used.

Four separate samples were prepared. The individual sample sizes were in the range 4mg  — 10mg for the ZEN material and 2mg to 4.5mg for the internal standard DMTP. Each sample was separately weighed into an aluminium weighing boat and then to avoid contact of the solvent with the metal boat, the contents of both were carefully transferred into a common glass vial and each emptied boat was reweighed. The amount of ZEN and DMTP transferred into the glass vial was determined by difference and this value was used for subsequent qNMR calculations. 1mL of deuterated solvent was added to the vial and the sample solution was mixed in a vortex shaker and checked visually for completeness of dissolution. Approximately 800µL of this solution was transferred into an NMR tube (HG-Type: high grade class, 8in , 5mm o.d., with PE cap) using a glass pasteur pipette.

5.2.3.  Choice of solvent and quantification signals

Because of the complexity of the ZEN proton spectrum in the upfield section of the spectrum (δ<5ppm ) the potential quantification peaks are limited to those occurring at chemical shift between 5ppm and 7ppm , corresponding to the aromatic (H-13 and H-15), olefinic (H-11 and H-12) and lactone bridge (H-3) protons.

CDCl3, DMSO- d 6 and acetone- d 6 were investigated as possible solvents. The hydrogen peak from the phenol at position 14 overlays the signal for H-11 at 5.7ppm , rendering this peak unsuitable for quantification. The signals due to the two aromatic hydrogens centered at 6.4ppm were associated in this material with small impurities at the baseline of the peak which were considered too close to be subtracted. The most attractive signals for quantification purposes were that at 7.0ppm corresponding to the H-12 proton and that at 5.0ppm due to H-3. The peak at 5.0ppm is a complex multiplet with lower intensity compared to the peak at 7.0ppm resulting in a lower relative signal to noise ratio. In addition all impurities in the material from either the ZEN or ZAN family will have a signal at a similar chemical shift. It was known from the LC characterization of the material (see Section 4.3) that ZAN was one of the major impurities in the material.

The peak at 7.0ppm was judged as more suitable for quantification as it would not include any contribution from the ZAN impurity or ZAN-related impurities. However in CDCl3 this peak is overlaid by the residual chloroform 13C satellite. In DMSO- d 6 the chemical shift of the peak moves to 6.6ppm . It is now in too close proximity to the signals for the aromatic hydrogen to be used for qNMR. However for acetone- d 6 the H-12 signal chemical shift remains at 7.0ppm and the residual solvent peak is well separated from the quantification region.

An unanticipated advantage was also discovered in the use of acetone- d 6 as solvent. It was observed that a significant curve occurred in the baseline of the spectra of ZEN in solution in CDCl3 or DMSO- d 6 which was not in evidence with spectra in acetone- d 6 . This may simply result from a contribution to the baseline from a broad acidic hydrogen signal in the aprotic solvents that is exchanged out in solution in acetone- d 6 due to the unavoidable presence therein of a small amount of water associated with the solvent. Whatever the source of the interference a bias to lower values was observed when qNMR was carried out on ZEN in solution CDCl3 and DMSO- d 6 compared with the value obtained in solution in acetone- d 6 . It is strongly advised to ONLY use acetone- d 6 for qNMR studies of ZEN materials.

Spectra illustrating the contrast between the baseline of the NMR spectrum of ZEN in acetone- d 6 and CDCl3 are reproduced in Appendix A1.6.

DMTP was selected as the internal standard selected for the qNMR study. [16] This material is readily soluble and stable in both non-polar and semi-polar solvents such as acetone- d 6 . The signal due to the four equivalent aromatic protons in DMTP which occur as a sharp singlet at 8.0ppm was used for quantification. The integration ratio was calculated against both the multiplet ZEN H-12 signal at 7.0ppm and the H-3 signal at 5.0ppm . The initial qNMR result for the quantification against the signal at 5.0ppm must be corrected for contributions from all three impurities identified by LC-methods (see Section 4.3) whereas the result using the signal at 7.0ppm need only be corrected for contributions from 6-dehydro ZEN and cis-ZEN impurities.

5.2.4.  NMR acquisition parameters

A JEOL ECS-400 spectrometer operating at 9.4T (400MHz for proton) equipped with a direct type automatic tuning (Royal) probe operating using the Delta software was used for all NMR data acquisition.

The general recommendations for optimizing spectrometer performance, determining the relevant NMR experiment parameters and undertaking a qNMR experiment as described in the BIPM Internal Standard Reference Data report for the use of DMTP for qNMR measurements [16] were followed. The final qNMR acquisition parameters are summarized in Table 5.

Table 5.  Acquisition parameters for qNMR.

ParameterValue
ZEN Sample size (mg)4 – 10
DMTP Sample size (mg)1.8 – 4.3
Number of Transients64
Receiver gain36
Acquisition time (s)4
Relaxation delay (s)56
Pulse offset (ppm)7.3
Spectral width (ppm)400
Data points639652
Temperature (K)298
13C-DecouplingOn
SpinningOff
Integral ratio (ZEN:DMTP)0.25 – 0.48

5.2.5.  qNMR signal integration

A baseline correction window of eighty times the FWHM was applied to each integrated signal. The integration range start and end points were placed fifty Hz beyond the visible edge of each signal. Results from four independent sample mixtures each measured four times were obtained.

5.2.6.  Value assignment and measurement uncertainty

Results from four independent sample mixtures each measured four times on the day of preparation were obtained with quantification using the one proton signal due for H-12 in ZEN at δ = 7.0 . The measurement uncertainty budget is reproduced below in Table 6. The integral ratio is the overall mean of the four replicate values obtained for each of the four samples, normalized for the different sample sizes used in their preparation. The standard uncertainty of the normalized ratio is the standard deviation of the mean based on the use of four independent samples. The relative contribution of each component to the uncertainty of the result for this material is displayed in Figure 6. The mass fraction content of “ZEN” in the material from this analysis, quantified against the 7.0ppm NMR peak in “ZEN”, was 998.0±1.8mgg1 , bearing in mind that this estimate includes the contributions from the 6-dehydro ZEN and cis-ZEN impurities.

Table 6.  Uncertainty budget for ZEN purity1 by qNMR using DMTP in acetone- d 6 .

Uncertainty sourcesValueTypeStandard UncertaintySensitivity coefficientUncertainty Component
IS/IA (repeatability)0.3382A0.000112950.7688393.28E-01
Analyte signal 1H Nuclei0.9998B0.0003-998.02931342.99E-01
IS signal 1H Nuclei3.9992B0.0004249.54002669.98E-02
Analyte Molar Mass318.364B0.01673.1342416475.22E-02
IS Molar Mass194.186B0.0085-5.1385254744.36E-02
Analyte mass (mg )4.0700B0.00124-245.16700433.05E-01
IS mass (mg )1.8326B0.00124544.4885456.77E-01
IS purity (mgg1 )999.3B0.40.9985286783.99E-01
Combined Uncertainty

9.08E-04

Purity of ZEN

998.0±1.8mgg1

Figure 6 — Relative uncertainty components: ZEN assignment using DMTP in acetone- d 6 .

Note in the uncertainty budget that the contribution from the gravimetric operations and the purity of the internal standard are as important to the overall uncertainty of the purity assignment as the contribution due to the repeatability of the integral ratio determination.

The qNMR assignment was repeated using the same set of NMR data obtained on the day of preparation of the sample but with quantification against the one proton signal for H-3 in ZEN at δ   5.0 . It was also repeated using the same samples and NMR acquisition and processing parameters three and seven days after the original sample preparation in order to evaluate the stability of the ZEN in solution. The qNMR assignments were obtained for each data set with quantification against both the δ 7.0ppm and δ 5.0ppm signals. The combined assignments are summarized in Table 7

Table 7

Time after prep (days)ZEN contenta (mg/g, δ = 7.0 )ZEN contentb (mg/g, δ = 5.0 )
T = 0 998 ± 2 995 ± 2
T = 3 996 ± 2 991 ± 2
T = 7 997 ± 2 994 ± 2

a  ZEN value uncorrected for 6-dehydroZEN and cis-ZEN impurities

b  ZEN value uncorrected for ZAN, 6-dehydroZEN and cis-ZEN impurities

5.4.  Water content by Karl Fischer titration

5.5.  Final ZEN Purity assignment

In the case of the OGO.178.a material the initial value of the purity of the uncorrected total “ZEN” content was 998.0±1.8mg/g . This was the mean of sixteen qNMR assignments (four samples each analysed in quadruplicate) using freshly prepared sample quantified against the signal at 7.0ppm .

The estimates of the impurity components in the material form the LC methods were:

ImpurityContent (mg/g )u (mg/g )Assignment
7-dehydro ZEN1.030.027LC-MS/MS and LC-DAD
ZAN1.230.007LC-MS/MS and LC-DAD
Iso-ZEN0.290.002LC-MS/MS
Total Residual solvent1.930.115NMR

For the final assignment of true ZEN content the initial qNMR value was corrected for 7-dehydroZEN and cis-ZEN content only as ZAN does not contribute to the signal at 7.0ppm . This gave an assigned value of the ZEN content of OGO.178a as 996.7±1.9mg/g , or for reporting purposes 997±2mg/g

6.  Acknowledgements

All NMR and LC studies were carried out by the co-authors of this document in the course of secondments at the BIPM. The support of the parent institution of each scientist in making them available for secondment to the BIPM is gratefully acknowledged.

Dr. Bruno Garrido wishes to acknowledge funding for his secondment from the Brazilian Ministry of Education under the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (CAPES) post-doctoral scholarship programme (process: 99999.007374/2015-01).


Appendix 1Annexes

A1.1.  Chemical structures of ZEN and related substances

Zearalenone (ZEN)

Zearalanone (ZAN)

α  — Zearalenol ( α -ZEL)

α  — Zearalanol ( α -ZAL)

β  — Zearalenol ( β -ZEL)

β  — Zearalanol ( β -ZAL)

cis-Zearalenone (cis-ZEN)

6-Dehydrozearalenone (6-dehydroZEN)

A1.2.  2D-NMR of ZEN

A1.2.1.  COSY

A1.2.2.  HSQC

A1.2.3.  TOCSY

A1.3.  1H NMR of ZEN

A1.3.1.  ZEN in CDCl3

A1.3.2.  ZEN in DMSO- d 6

A1.3.3.  ZEN in acetone- d 6

A1.4.  Residual solvent content by NMR

Figure 1.1 — CH2Cl2 residue in ZEN

Figure 1.2 — CH3OH and Et2O (?) residue in ZEN

A1.5.  qNMR of ZEN

Figure 1.3 — 1H qNMR spectrum of ZEN and DMTP in CDCl3.

A1.6.  Baseline contrast CDCl3 v. Acetone- d 6

Figure 1.4 and Figure 1.5 display the observed, expanded baseline of the NMR spectrum of ZEN in CDCl3 and acetone- d 6 respectively.

Figure 1.4 — NMR spectrum of ZEN in CDCl3

Figure 1.5 — NMR spectrum of ZEN in acetone- d 6


References

[1]  BIPM CBKT programme: Safe Food and Feed in Developing Economies

[2]  Betina, V. (Ed.) in CRC Handbook of Naturally Occurring Food Toxicants, CRC Press (1989)

[3]  Lorenz, N., Dänicke, S., Edler, L. et al. Mycotoxin Res 2019, 35, 27.

[4]  Zinedine, A., Soriano, J., Molto, J., Manes,J. Food Chem. Toxicology, 2007, 45, 1-18

[5]  JRC Mycotoxins Factsheet, 4th Ed. (2011)

[6]  De Bièvre, P., Dybkaer, R., Fajgelj, A. and Hibbert, D.; Pure Appl. Chem., 2011, 83, 1873–1935

[7]  ISO 17511:2003 International Organization for Standardization. In vitro diagnostic medical devices — Measurement of quantities in biological samples — Metrological traceability of values assigned to calibrators and control materials. 1st edition. August 2003. Geneva. https://www.iso.org/standard/30716.html.

[8]  Metzler, M.; Mycotox. Res. 2011, 27, 1

[9]  Merck Index, 9th Edition (1976), p 1306

[10]  Krska et al.: J. AOAC Intl. 2003, 86, 722

[11]  Jaouen, G. Et al; Magn. Reson. Chem., 1990, 28, 835

[12]  Nakanishi, Koji, ed. One-dimensional and two-dimensional NMR Spectra by Modern Pulse Techniques. (1990). [ISBN 0-935702-63-6]

[13]  Gottlieb, H.; J. Org. Chem. 1997, 62, 7512

[14]  Holzgrabe, U. (ed); NMR Spectroscopy in Pharmaceutical Analysis, Elsevier, 2008

[15]  Bharti, S.; Roy, R.; Trends Anal. Chem., 2012, 35, 5-26

[16]  BIPM-2019/1 Rapport BIPM-2019/1 : qNMR Internal Standard Reference Data for Dimethyl Terephthalate [BIPM-2019/1]

[17]  Yamazaki, T. ; Nakamura, S. ; Saito, T.; Metrologia, 2017, 54, 224

Document Control

Authors:Steven Westwood (BIPM), Ralf Josephs (BIPM), Tiphaine Choteau (BIPM), Xiuqin Li (NIM, China), Bruno Garrido (INMETRO, Brazil), Ilker Un (TUBITAK UME, Turkey), and Taichi Yamazaki (NMIJ, Japan)